11 Thoughtful Thanksgiving Hostess Gifts to Show Your Gratitude

1. Hand-Painted Pumpkins or Giftables by a Local Artist
   These aren’t your average pumpkins! As a Florida artist, I’ve created hand-painted pumpkins that are floral, fun, and designed to be a keepsake for years to come. Whether they’re used as a centerpiece or as part of the fall decor, these pumpkins bring a burst of color and joy. They’re a unique way to say “thank you” with a personal touch that will remind your host of the special day long after the leftovers are gone. My hand-painted limited edition Christmas ornaments are another great giftable option! Mini canvas shelf sitters make great gifts too!

2. Locally Made Organic Beeswax or Soy Candles
   Hosting Thanksgiving means setting the right mood, and there’s nothing like the warm glow of candles to make the evening feel cozy. Organic beeswax or soy candles are an eco-friendly, clean-burning option that also come with that beautiful golden glow. Opt for fall scents like cinnamon, chai, or cedar. Look for candles in reusable glass jars for an extra sustainable touch, so your host can enjoy them even after the holiday ends. These artisan soy candles are absolutely *gorgeous* and possibly too pretty to burn but they're on my gifting list this year!

3. Artisan Olive Oil and Herb Blend Set
   Give your host a gift they can use to create future meals. A bottle of high-quality extra virgin olive oil paired with an organic herb blend is perfect for those who love to cook. Choose oils that come in pretty bottles, and opt for herbs that are versatile, like rosemary, thyme, or an Italian mix. It’s a gourmet gift that’s both practical and thoughtful, perfect for any food-loving host.

4. Handcrafted Wooden Serving Utensils
   For the host who enjoys entertaining, a set of sustainably made wooden serving utensils or a small charcuterie board is a gift they’ll use again and again. Handcrafted from local wood or sourced sustainably, these utensils are a beautiful, functional addition to any kitchen. Plus, they’re a long-lasting reminder of the time shared together.

5. Eco-Friendly Kitchen Towels
   Kitchen towels always come in handy, especially during a big Thanksgiving meal! Choose ones made from organic cotton or bamboo, and go for natural, earthy tones or fun seasonal prints. For a unique, artful touch, check out Studio Akina’s hand-dyed kitchen towels and napkins—each one is a one-of-a-kind piece that brings color and craftsmanship to any kitchen. They’re eco-friendly, reusable, and a stylish upgrade to any kitchen. Practical gifts can still be thoughtful, especially when they’re beautiful too!

6. Homemade Granola or Spiced Nuts in Glass Jars
   If you’re looking for something homemade and heartfelt, try putting together a batch of granola or spiced nuts. Package them in a cute reusable glass jar, and add a ribbon for a festive touch. It’s a healthy, delicious snack your host can enjoy in the days following the feast. You could even include a recipe card if they want to try making it themselves!

7. Organic Potted Herbs
   A small pot of organic herbs like rosemary, sage, or thyme is a gift that keeps on giving. Not only will the plant add a touch of greenery to your host’s home, but it’s also useful for future cooking. Choose a beautiful pot that complements their style, and it’s sure to be a gift they treasure—and use—for months to come.

8. Handmade Ceramic Mug with Specialty Tea Blend
   After a long day of hosting, your host will probably appreciate some time to unwind. A handmade ceramic mug, paired with a loose-leaf organic tea blend, makes a cozy and thoughtful gift. Opt for a mug made by a local artist or pottery shop for a unique, artisanal feel, and select a soothing tea blend like chamomile or peppermint to help your host relax after the big event.

9. Handmade Pumpkin Spice Sugar Scrub & Soap Set
   Pamper your host with a little self-care! A homemade pumpkin spice sugar scrub, paired with artisanal soap made from organic oils, is a lovely gift that feels luxurious without being over the top. You can easily make a sugar scrub with simple ingredients like sugar, coconut oil, and pumpkin spice. Package it in a small glass jar and pair it with a handcrafted soap for a spa-like experience at home.

10. Locally Made Honey or Jam Set
    Support local producers by gifting a set of locally sourced honey or small-batch jams. Choose flavors that capture the season, like spiced pear, cranberry, or wildflower honey. These edible gifts are perfect for your host to enjoy the morning after Thanksgiving or to save for future meals.

11. Organic Hot Cocoa Kit
    Who doesn’t love a cozy cup of hot cocoa after a busy day? Put together an organic hot cocoa kit with gourmet hot cocoa mix, dark chocolate shavings, and artisanal marshmallows. Package it all in a decorative jar or tin with a festive ribbon. It’s a sweet treat your host can enjoy on a chilly evening, perfect for unwinding after all the holiday excitement.

And a bonus gift idea...

For a cozy and fragrant gift, consider a wild-harvested organic simmer pot bundle—perfect for filling the home with natural scents, whether for Thanksgiving or as a thoughtful holiday treat. I have these in my Etsy cart to use as gift toppers for Christmas since they come in a pack of 3! They are delightful any time of year.

Each of these gifts is designed to show your host just how much you appreciate their hard work and hospitality. Whether you go the artisanal route or make something yourself, giving a thoughtful, creative gift is the perfect way to say “thank you” and bring a little extra joy to their holiday season.

And one more little reminder as we head into the holiday season:

Many of these unique gifts can be found on platforms like Etsy, where you can support small businesses directly. I know Etsy can be overwhelming with the sea of options, so to make it easy, try filtering your search by location to find talented artisans closest to home. Use specific keywords like “organic,” “small batch,” or even your city or state to discover makers who align with your values and preferences. Shopping this way not only brings thoughtful gifts but also supports your local creative community.

It’s a great time to remember that shopping small makes a big difference. When you buy from local artists and small businesses, you’re supporting someone's passion, creativity, and livelihood—trust me, we do a happy dance every time! Big box stores may be convenient, but they don’t bring the same joy that comes from supporting your community. This Thanksgiving, consider choosing handmade and locally sourced gifts whenever you can.